Real Grace
One of my recent suggestions in my book Living Spirituality for reading Scripture was that we develop wise and Spirit-fired reading habits. I think we need to be more intentional about and actively aware of the significant dangers of misreading the text. Efforts to counter this, combined with better readings, will help transform our communities and churches, while inspiring a more faithful and fitting embodiment of Scripture, which can then be lived out into the world. The magnitude of this could have a profound impact on highlighting and affirming God’s missional purposes in reconciling the world to himself in Christ. Here’s the text I’d like you to consider. Read it carefully, and if you have time read the whole letter.
First this: Key points of 2 Corinthians 7
The stage then is now set for the second major part of this letter. As readers we have received another glimpse into the complex context of Paul and the Corinthians and the theological and personal concerns related to them. Hopefully, this perspective will help us to better understand this letter and in so doing to refocus our attention on the real gems that it offers us in a diversity of ways. In closing let me just point you to a few of these:
1) Conflict in relationships – how to view the other is important, especially in the Christian community – the truth of the gospel is at stake.
2) Struggles and difficulties in our lives are not ends in and of themselves. God is the God of all comfort.
3) Dangers of bringing the truth of the gospel into question should cause us to reflect carefully on our actions.
4) Godly grief leads to repentance and repentance leads to salvation and salvation to God – Salvation and God are the referents of repentance, which lead us into community with God and each other.
5) God is at work in our lives and this should make us aware of many things, including the importance of justice.
6) Where do our own loyalties lie? How are we to practice a hermeneutics of trust and suspicion in life giving ways that represent the gospel?
2 Corinthians 8: 1-15
1 And now, brothers and sisters, we want you to know about the grace that God has given the Macedonian churches.
2 Out of the most severe affliction, their overflowing joy and their extreme poverty welled up in rich generosity.
3 For I testify that they gave as much as they were able, and even beyond their ability. Entirely on their own,
4 they urgently pleaded with us for the privilege of sharing in this service to the saints.
5 And they did not do as we expected, but they gave themselves first to the Lord and then to us in keeping with God's will.
6 So we urged Titus, since he had earlier made a beginning, to bring also to completion this act of grace on your part.
7 But just as you excel in everything—in faith, in speech, in knowledge, in complete earnestness and in your love for us—see that you also excel in this grace of giving.
8 I am not commanding you, but I want to test the sincerity of your love by comparing it with the earnestness of others. 9 For you know the grace of our Lord Jesus Christ, that though he was rich, yet for your sakes he became poor, so that you through his poverty might become rich. 10 And here is my advice about what is best for you in this matter: Last year you were the first not only to give but also to have the desire to do so. 11 Now finish the work, so that your eager willingness to do it may be matched by your completion of it, according to your means. 12 For if the willingness is there, the gift is acceptable according to what one has, not according to what he does not have.
13 Our desire is not that others might be relieved while you are hard pressed, but that there might be equality. 14 At the present time your plenty will supply what they need, so that in turn their plenty will supply what you need. Then there will be equality, 15 as it is written: "He who gathered much did not have too much, and he who gathered little did not have too little."
8:1-7
In chapter 8 Paul is going to revisit, via Macedonia, the matter of the collection for the Jerusalem church, which he already mentioned back in 1 Cor. 16. This collection had been initiated, but not yet completed and therefore he wants to raise the subject again in anticipation of the return of Titus to Corinth . However, this is not Paul’s only concern here. He also targets the centrality of grace and gives it a careful exposition in chapters 8-9.
In verse 1 it is clear that we enter new territory. Paul first of all wants his readers to know something of the grace of God toward the Macedonian churches. This grace relates, as verse 2 points out, to overflowing joy in the midst of affliction and the riches of their focused generosity. Normally, Paul uses the more specific word “charis” or “charisma” for a gifting/grace of this type, which is often connected with something received, but here he refers to overflowing joy and overflowing generosity. God’s grace has been given, and in Paul’s context continues to be given, which results in an overflowing joy and in the Macedonians’ unprecedented generosity. Perhaps this quite unusual concept, the reciprocity of grace received and generosity given is something we would do well to think more and better about. Could it be that there is a place for God's grace to us being revealed through our grace; in this case, our generosity to the other?
Notice the context of the Macedonian churches, which Paul no doubt uses to serve as an example to the Corinthian church. Their generosity is shown in the midst of severe affliction, which may have been due to Roman possession of their land and material wealth. Yet, out of overflowing joy and the depth of their poverty they were able to manifest God’s grace. It is likely that in comparison to the Corinthian church, the Macedonian churches were fairly poor, but what counts for the apostle here is their attitude and spirit, not necessarily the quantity of what is offered.
Paul will now explain this in verses 3-4. He writes that these Christians have given far beyond their own ability and in an unsolicited manner. God’s grace in these churches is manifested in their sacrificial care for the other. Not only in their case was this sacrifice not requested, but they actually appealed to have the privilege of participating in a collection for the saints in Jerusalem who were more poverty stricken than themselves.
The Macedonians’ giving went far beyond expectation, as verse 5 goes on to point out. It originated and culminated in their giving themselves to the Lord and also to the apostle through God’s will. Perhaps Paul has at least two points here. First, he is aiming to defuse any Corinthian plot in regard to the accusation that he is only after their money. Second, he is implying that the Macedonian churches recognized his God-given apostleship and authority, both of which are validated in his serving others for Jesus’ sake (4:5).
In verse 6 Paul moves more directly to the matter at hand. Titus will return to Corinth . As a result of the unanticipated interest in the collection by the Macedonian churches Titus is going to seek to bring the “act of grace” which had begun in Corinth to its completion.
With verse 7 Paul draws this section to a close. He directly challenges the church in Corinth to bring to completion the grace of giving, which in this specific case is the collection for the impoverished in Jerusalem . As the church in Corinth was notably known for its manifestation of certain other spiritual gifts, Paul here picks up the verb “overflow” from verse 2 and lists a number of graces the Corinthians do overflow in. If this is the case, should they not also overflow in the grace of giving?
The church in Corinth may have had a problem with a focus on the other, perhaps both within and outside its own community context. No doubt there were strengths in the church, but this seems to be a glaring weakness, which may have been due to an insufficient understanding of grace. Grace is not only to be received for oneself, but it is to be given to the other.
8:8-15
Paul’s exhortation is quickly followed in verse 8 by a sort of disclaimer. He is not commanding this of the Corinthians, as it is unlikely that he had received any such command from the Risen One. He rather wants to know where the level of their love stands with respect to that of the Macedonians.
In this context, the apostle again returns to the wonderful reality of interchange in verse 9. He has already written of this back in 5:21 (read this). No doubt the aim here with this use of metaphors is to heighten and sharpen the understanding of grace, while also addressing the matter at hand. But how does this work out? The model of grace that the Corinthians know of is the Lord Jesus Christ. What they may not have realized is the analogy between this grace and the grace of giving to others. As Christ has become something that he is not so that they might become something they are not, he takes their place in order that they might be graced with his. So too, grace has to do with not only receiving, but giving. Again, perhaps this is a new configuration of grace for us. It may be appropriate to say it this way: grace is for passing on, but we should stress that its passing on must be rooted in it first being received. In other words, passing on grace is not merely based on performance, but on reception which is the referent for its being passed on. The life and work of Christ are “other” focused so that those who receive it might move from being self centered towards being Other and others centered. This other centered capacity in turn will affirm the truth of receivers being new selves. The perception of interchange then functions on at least two levels: first, Christ and only Christ can stand for us. The one who was rich becomes poor so that others might receive grace. Second, those who receive this unique grace may then pass it on to another. Grace received is then refigured through grace given. As this grace has been given to them the Corinthians should carefully consider the grace of giving to the other in need.
In verses 10-12, following the metaphorical power of verse 9, Paul moves into giving his advice to the Corinthians more directly. Remember, he has done a similar thing on another issue back in 1 Cor. 7. This advice is what he understands to be the most helpful for them. He looks back in time in order to remind the Corinthians that it would be most helpful for them if there was a greater symmetry between their wanting and their doing.
It is true that they were “not only” the first to start a collection for others, “but also” wanted to accomplish this. However, what had broken down was the doing part of the reality. The Corinthians wanted to initiate something, yet perhaps as many of us, the actual doing of this is where configured grace – the grace we’ve received never becomes refigured in our own lives in being passed on to the other. Wanting the right things is admirable; however this commendable desire must reach the other in actual doing. The Corinthians’ willingness, their voluntary response to a need was there, but this now must translate into action that accomplishes something in the world.
Notice that this completed action, from Paul's perspective, is related to the capacity that this church has. They are being encouraged to go ahead and do what they said they would within the context of what is possible. What is most important here is the attitude of giving, which is in turn what makes it acceptable before God.
In verses 13-14 Paul shifts direction somewhat. With another explanatory “for” flowing from the assurance that he is not encouraging the Corinthian believer to give what he or she does not have, Paul anticipates another question or concern.
Would it be appropriate if the one profits at the other’s expense? He is not suggesting, in this context, that some be in poverty, while the others are taking advantage. What he aims at is equality. But what does Paul have in mind here? Perhaps, in looking ahead, his point is that the Corinthians will receive the fellowship and prayers of the saints as 9:14 states, and that if circumstances were reversed, they also would benefit from aid of a similar type. Verse 15 brings the section to a close with a quote from Exodus 16:18. The principle in this passage is that those who had a considerable amount had none left over and those who had less had enough. As God was concerned with equality during Israel 's wilderness period, Paul now stresses its ongoing relevance at the present time.
In conclusion here are a few things to think more and better about.
1) It is essential for us to understand and live out the reality that God's grace expresses itself in both being received and also in being given. This expression is rooted in the grace of the Lord Jesus Christ and the reality of interchange between us and him, which takes place as a result of it. In turn this reality brings about an attitude of overflowing joy leading to the grace of generosity towards others. What kind of world makes this interchange possible? What kind of world makes it possible to give as much as one is able, even beyond one's ability? What kind of world allows one to overflow in the grace of giving and to actually do grace? The world of the biblical text is the only one that both configures these truths, while at the same time opening possibilities for us to take part in this world, and as we do so, to have our lives refigured through participating in receiving and giving God’s grace.
2) Paul’s advice is that there be a greater symmetry in the lives of Christians between wanting and doing. A practical following through with grace is the one the piercing marks of a new self who participates in the interchange that the Lord Jesus Christ has brought about.
3) Equality in graces is to be an essential reality in the Christian community as it lives its faith out into the world.